Keto is the diet of the decade. As with many things in nutrition, the ketogenic diet is surrounded by myths, misinformation, and exaggeration. The truth about keto is that it’s better than the alarmists would have you believe, and not the panacea that your best friend thinks it is.
What are the benefits of keto? What are the risks? Is keto a diet you should follow long-term? What supplements should I use on keto?
I’ll tackle these questions and a lot more in this complete guide to keto. Whether you’re brand new to the diet, or you’re a nutrition coach and need some talking points to use with clients, this guide will give you answers to questions you’ve been asking, and answers to questions you haven’t asked yet.
As you’ll see, it’s my longest article to date. There’s a lot to cover with keto, so if you’re looking for something specific, use the shortcuts below and jump to the section you need.
- Intro: Keto Experimentation, Experience, and Research
- What Is Keto?
- Keto Diet Health Benefits
- 1. Restores Mitochondrial Function
- 2. Supports Significant Weight Loss
- 3. Improves Insulin Sensitivity and Blood Sugar Levels
- 4. Improves Sex Hormone Balance In Men And Women
- 5. Improves Markers Of Cardiovascular Health
- 6. Possibly Augments Cancer Treatment
- 7. Improves Brain and Nervous System Function
- 8. Slows Effects of Aging
- 9. Enhances Some Types Of Exercise Performance
- Keto Diet Side Effects
- Top 9 Keto Diet Mistakes
- Keto Supplementation
- What Do You Do After Keto?
Intro: Keto Experimentation, Experience, and Research
It’s been over a decade since I wrote my first article on low-carb or ketogenic diets. Since that time, I have years of personal experience, as well as insights from clients who’ve followed the diet. I’ve seen successes and failures.
Here’s what I believe based on experimentation, experience with others, and from combing through the research:
- The Ketogenic Diet is a powerful tool to help someone reclaim his or her health
- In the short-term, the diet offers numerous health benefits
- In the long-term, the benefits of the diet are less certain, and potential negative impact on mental and physical wellbeing need to be considered
- I’m strongly in favor of the short-term use of the ketogenic diet, and feel for most people, long-term adherence to the diet is unnecessary and possibly detrimental
The average person today would benefit tremendously by following a ketogenic diet for three to twelve months. However, once they’ve improved their health and fitness, I recommend most people transition to a diet that includes some carbs.
What Is Keto?
Keto is short for “ketogenic diet,” a diet pattern that significantly limits carbohydrates, emphasizes dietary fat, and causes low levels of glycogen in order to stimulate production of ketone bodies.
Elevated ketones make a ketogenic diet “ketogenic,” and separate a ketogenic diet from a standard low-carb diet.
Your liver produces endogenous ketones (or ketone bodies) in response to starvation, fasting (even intermittent fasting), or when you’re on a very low-carb, high-fat diet. Exercise, when it’s intense enough and done for long enough, also stimulates ketone production.
In the absence of available carbs, ketones become a preferred energy source.
Ketosis Vs Ketoacidosis
For years, the medical community warned people against the ketogenic diet, confusing nutritional ketosis for ketoacidosis.
Ketoacidosis most often occurs in people with undiagnosed Type I diabetes, or in patients with Type I diabetes who don’t use their insulin. For people with Type I diabetes, it can be life-threatening. In the complete absence of insulin, the body breaks down fat at an accelerated rate, and produces very high levels of ketones. The concentration gets so high that the blood becomes acidic.
In more rare cases, ketoacidosis occurs in people with severe Type II diabetes, in alcoholics, from starvation, and has even been seen during pregnancy.
Nutritional ketosis is a diet strategy used to maximize the use of stored body fat, which also increases production of ketone bodies. Though nutritional ketosis and ketoacidosis are both states where ketone bodies are elevated, the concentration is much, much higher in ketoacidosis.
Today, a plethora of research shows that a ketogenic diet is safe for most people, and distinctly different from ketoacidosis.
Keto For Disease Treatment
Keto has its roots in disease treatment, not as a health and fitness tool.
The ketogenic diet was first used in the 1920s as a treatment for epilepsy. Patients were put on diets consisting of 80% or more fat. Protein was limited to about 0.45 grams per pound body weight per day. Not only did patients experience fewer seizures, they also improved blood sugar, insulin, and lipid levels while reducing body fat.
Keto Macronutrients For Disease Treatment
Doctors may put patients on the therapeutic version of a ketogenic diet for treating diseases like epilepsy, certain types of cancer, type II diabetes, etc. The general outline of a therapeutic ketogenic diet is extreme and may be necessary for dealing with medical conditions.
- Dietary fat makes up 80% or more of total daily calorie intake
- Protein limited to 0.45 grams per pound body weight per day
- Carbohydrates limited to 20-30 grams per day, or less
This extreme version of a ketogenic diet causes ketone levels in the blood to rise to 3.0 mmol/L or higher. At this “deep state of ketosis,” seizure rates drop significantly. Since then, the ketogenic diet has been used in the treatment of other metabolic and neurological diseases.
Dr. Thomas Seyfried researches the ketogenic diet and cancer, and feels that a higher range of 3.0-6.0 mmol/L is necessary for cancer treatment.
This high concentration of ketones is necessary for treating neurological and metabolic disease, but isn’t necessary, and could be detrimental for those pursuing general health and fitness.
Unfortunately, many people who evangelize the benefits of keto don’t know the difference, and suggest the disease treatment version should be used for generally healthy people. It should not.
|Level of Ketosis||Blood Ketones|
|Light Ketosis||0.5-1.0 mmol/L|
|Nutritional Ketosis (optimal)||1.0-3.0 mmol/L|
|Therapeutic Ketosis||3.0-6.0 mmol/L|
Keto For Health, Fitness, and Improved Body Composition
Jeff Volek and Steve Phinney, leading experts in ketogenic and low-carb diets, coined the term “nutritional ketosis” to describe the optimal ketone concentration for health and fitness.
Though people still produce ketones, it isn’t at the level of those being treated for disease. Nutritional ketosis can produce up to 150 grams of ketones per day.
Provided you are generally healthy, and exercising regularly, you can eat a little more carbohydrates and more protein while maintaining nutritional ketosis.
Keto Macronutrients For Health, Fitness, and Body Composition
I recommend using nutritional ketosis as a starting point for weight loss and improved health. The closer you get to “optimal” health, fitness, and body composition, the more I would recommend transitioning away from keto, and towards a diet higher in protein and carbohydrates (and lower in fat, of course).
- 0.75 grams of protein per pound body weight per day
- Net Carbohydrates 30-100 grams per day, depending on level of activity and fitness
- Fat fills in the remainder of the daily calorie needs
What are net carbs? Total carbohydrate counts include fiber. However, fiber isn’t digested like normal carbohydrates, and has no effect on blood sugar and insulin levels. Therefore, carbohydrate counts on keto consider “net carbs.” This is the total carbohydrate count minus fiber.
Keto is often promoted with the idea of eating unlimited amounts of fat. Though a ketogenic diet might provide a metabolic advantage, calories do still count.
If you’re binging on bacon, butter, and cheese, there’s no need for your body to use the fat you’ve stored under your skin. The percentage of fat you eat compared to carbohydrates and protein is high, but that doesn’t mean you can eat unlimited amounts of fat.
I also need to address the fear of protein when following keto.
Because protein raises insulin slightly, a rise in insulin could take you temporarily out of ketosis. That’s a concern for a patient with epilepsy, as it could induce a seizure.
For general health, it’s more important to get enough protein to support growth or maintenance of muscle than it is to stay in ketosis 24/7.
The keto community has created a fear of eating protein because protein raises insulin. Yet, that’s exactly how things are supposed to work. Insulin helps shuttle protein’s amino acids into your cells. In my opinion, the importance of sufficient protein intake far outweighs the effect of a temporary rise in insulin.
Keto Diet Health Benefits
The volumes of supporting research for low-carb and ketogenic diets is more than convincing, especially when applied to the average overweight and insulin resistant adult.
The health benefits of keto are what appear to be accurate, based on today’s existing body of research.
It’s possible, likely even, that in 20 years, we’ll know and understand our bodies differently than we do today.
1. Restores Mitochondrial Function
Keto improves the function, and can increase the size and number of, your mitochondria.
This is likely the most important benefit of keto (I know…you thought the ultimate benefit was bacon. Sorry to be a buzzkill).
Mitochondria are the power plants of your cells. They generate adenosine triphosphate (ATP), the ultimate unit of energy. You need ATP to move, breathe, digest food, and read this article. Without mitochondria and the ATP they produce, you would have no life.
Most diseases either cause mitochondrial dysfunction, or mitochondrial dysfunction contributes to the disease.
The causes of mitochondrial dysfunction include:
- Excessive carbohydrate consumption or high blood sugar
- Sedentary lifestyle
- Insufficient sleep
- Exposure to excessive free radicals
- Insufficient micronutrient intake
- Exposure to environmental toxins
Although mitochondria produce free radicals on their own, simply by producing energy, the modern lifestyle and diet exposes our bodies to much higher levels than our bodies can handle on their own.
Keto supports mitochondrial function by minimizing reliance on sugar, maximizing use of fat, reducing inflammation, and creating a more efficient energy source: ketones.
As your mitochondrial function improves and you feel better, you move and exercise more, which further stimulates mitochondrial biogenesis.
2. Supports Significant Weight Loss
At least in the short-term, keto is extremely effective for weight loss, and possibly superior to other diets for fat loss.
The actual cause of the better weight loss benefits remains to be discovered. Many theories exist, and all probably contribute to weight loss.
What Causes Weight Loss On A Ketogenic Diet?
The following are the five theories on why keto is so effective for weight loss. More than likely each of the theories is involved:
- Reduction in hunger, due to the appetite-suppressing effects of protein and ketones
- Decreased need for calories, since fat stores provide more of the body’s energy needs
- The high “metabolic cost” of creating glucose from protein/amino acids, which could burn up to 600 calories per day
- Reduced cravings for carbohydrate-rich foods since blood sugar stays steady
- Hormonal shifts, such as increases in growth hormone and testosterone
In my opinion, it doesn’t matter how it works better. Low-carb and ketogenic diets lead to better weight loss, and are easier to adhere to than calorie-controlled low-fat diets. That’s all that matters for the average person.
To be fair, some research studies show little to no difference in weight loss between low-carb/keto and low-fat/low-calorie diets.
However, these are often studies where researchers follow up with people months to years after they start a diet, and see what kind of results they’ve gotten.
Of course, most people don’t stick to the diet long-term, and the different diet groups end up eating more alike than different.
If you follow the diet, it works. If you don’t, it doesn’t. That’s why long-term studies show no differences in weight loss between low-carb and low-fat diets. It’s not because the diet doesn’t work. It’s because long-term, most people don’t work the diet.
A 2018 study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) showed that after 12 months, “there was no significant difference in weight change between a healthy low-fat diet vs a healthy low-carbohydrate diet.”
I was curious about what they were calling “low-carb” versus “low-fat.”
It turns out, the low-fat diet group ate an average of 48% of calories from carbohydrates. The low-carb ate a considerable amount of carbs: 30%! On a 2000 calorie diet, that would be a whopping 150 grams per day.
In my opinion, that’s hardly “low-carb.” It’s also based on people’s dietary recalls, which are notoriously inaccurate. Of course, most news sources failed to consider this when they promoted the headlines that low-carb wasn’t more effective than a low-calorie diet.
3. Improves Insulin Sensitivity and Blood Sugar Levels
Since carbs cause elevated blood sugar, and over time, chronically elevated blood sugar leads to insulin resistance, it should come as no surprise that keto improves average blood sugar levels and helps restore insulin sensitivity.
Those on a ketogenic diet should see a significant improvement in HbA1c, fasting blood sugar and insulin levels.
Besides limiting the damage the carbs do, ketones can improve glucose uptake as well.
Obesity and type II diabetes often go hand-in-hand, but not always.
15-20% of those with type II diabetes are at a “normal” weight
The cool thing about keto is that many people restore insulin sensitivity and can eventually eat a reasonable amount of carbs again. To get to that point, you’ll need to give them up for a while. That’s just the way it is.
4. Improves Sex Hormone Balance In Men And Women
Chronically elevated glucose causes different responses in men than in women.
Chronically elevated blood sugar and insulin decrease testosterone and increase estrogen in men, and increase testosterone and decrease estrogen in women.
In men, low testosterone contributes to depression, muscle loss, lack of motivation, cognitive problems, infertility, grumpy old man syndrome (even when a guy isn’t “old”), and moobs…man boobs.
In a study of healthy, college-aged, resistance-trained men, when compared to a Standard American Diet, a ketogenic diet increased testosterone. The men in the ketogenic group increased testosterone from an average of 570 ng/dL to 690 ng/dL, about a 21% increase.
What increases testosterone in the short-term for men on keto? The theories include:
- increased cholesterol consumption, as cholesterol is a building block for testosterone
- lower fiber intake, since fiber helps remove cholesterol (I have my doubts about this one, since fiber also helps remove estrogen)
- lower belly fat (visceral fat) which increases estrogen and lowers testosterone
In my opinion, a low-carb, but not ketogenic, high-protein diet would have done the same thing.
Chronically high insulin in women affects testosterone and estrogen in the opposite directions of men. Testosterone goes up and estrogen stays the same or goes down.
When testosterone gets too high in comparison to estrogen, women develop “central obesity.” They get more of an apple shape than a pear shape. They lose their curves.
Excess testosterone in women:
- increases facial hair growth
- contributes to infertility
- increases heart disease risk
- causes abnormal cycles
- raises triglycerides
- raises inflammatory levels
- causes central obesity – they develop more of an apple shape than a pear shape (they lose their curves)
These are classic signs of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS).
It’s no surprise then, to find that women who follow a ketogenic diet experience significant improvements in PCOS symptoms.
5. Improves Markers Of Cardiovascular Health
Your ratio-of-triglycerides to HDL is one of the simplest and most telling indicators of cardiovascular disease risk.
|Triglycerides / HDL Ratio||Risk Level|
|1:1 or Less||Optimum|
Triglycerides rise when you eat a lot of carbs. They fall when you restrict carbs.
Not surprisingly, a ketogenic diet dramatically improves this ratio.
Cholesterol levels responds less predictably than triglycerides with ketogenic diets. In some, cholesterol levels go up. In others, it goes down. However, cholesterol by itself is a poor predictor of cardiovascular risk anyway.
If you still worry about eating more cholesterol on a ketogenic diet, consider the findings of a published review of available research from 2011 in the British Journal of Nutrition:
Epidemiological data do not support a link between dietary cholesterol and CVD (cardiovascular disease).Lecerf JM, de Lorgeril M
Research also shows ketogenic diets protect heart muscle tissue by reducing free radicals, and improve its efficiency and energy reserves. Animal models also show ketosis even prevents heart tissue damage from heart attacks and strokes.
6. Possibly Augments Cancer Treatment
Most cancer cells thrive on glucose. An excessively high-carbohydrate intake could cause mitochondrial dysfunction, and mitochondrial dysfunction could cause cancer cell development.
This does not mean carbs cause cancer. It simply means that when someone consumes enough to cause mitochondrial damage, they could contribute to cancer cell development.
And, if those cancer cells begin to multiply, they’ll grow best in a glucose-rich environment.
A number of animal studies have shown that a ketogenic diet slows tumor growth, which sounds promising. It appears that most cancer cells cannot use ketones, so a ketogenic diet robs most cancer cells of their fuel source, while providing an alternative fuel for healthy cells.
However, we’re far from a definitive answer in how much of an effect a ketogenic diet would have on cancer cell growth.
A group of researcher found evidence that breast cancer cells can use ketones to actually fuel their growth. They concluded:
…given our current findings that ketones increase tumor growth, cancer patients and their dietitians may want to reconsider the use of a “ketogenic diet” as a form of anticancer therapy.Bonuccelli, et al.
Most evidence suggests a ketogenic diet might help and probably wouldn’t hurt in supporting cancer therapy. However, there is no evidence at this point that a ketogenic diet prevents cancer. I’m stressing this because there’s a lot of bad advice on the internet that might make it sound like “keto cures cancer.” The research does not support that statement at this time.
7. Improves Brain and Nervous System Function
As I mentioned earlier, the ketogenic diet has a significant impact on reducing the occurrence of seizures. That’s really how the diet first got popular. It has even been shown to be effective in treating infantile spasms, a rare form of epileptic seizure.
Some people who eliminate seizures with a ketogenic diet remain seizure-free, even after transitioning to a more “normal” diet, which suggests the ketogenic diet may fix the cause of the seizures. How cool is that?!
Other nervous system-related conditions where keto may help include:
- Parkinson’s and Alzheimer’s disease
- Multiple Sclerosis
- Traumatic brain and spinal cord injuries
- Brain cancer
- Sleep disorders
- Migraine headaches
Ketone bodies may also be neuroprotective in degenerative brain diseases, not necessarily curing the diseases, but perhaps slowing their progression. A ketogenic diet may also help slow memory loss and confusion associated with dementia.
8. Slows Effects of Aging
A ketogenic diet (as well as intermittent fasting) creates a similar metabolic effect as chronic calorie restriction, without restricting calories.
It reduces free radical production. Free radicals are the main cause of aging and cell death. Keto also reduces inflammation, which causes pain and tissue damage. As I mentioned above, it can also be neuroprotective.
This is why keto is thought to possibly enhance longevity, but it’s theoretical at the moment. Fortunately, if it does enhance longevity, it does so without sacrificing quality of life as chronic calorie-restriction does.
9. Enhances Some Types Of Exercise Performance
Aerobic endurance athletes do well on a ketogenic diet. Aerobic exercise relies on efficient use of fat for fuel, which the ketogenic diet clearly provides.
It may be helpful in intermittent aerobic sports, such as baseball, basketball and soccer, where athletes have short bursts of sprints intermixed with longer periods of slower movement and running.
For general fitness and muscle building in experienced lifters, a ketogenic diet doesn’t seem to provide any advantage for those who are healthy.
Keto can be detrimental for:
- Muscular endurance
- Mountain biking
- Crossfit or other high-intensity training
Keto Diet Side Effects
The skeptics often ask, “What are the dangers of keto,” or “What are the keto diet side effects?” While I wouldn’t go so far as to say there are dangers of keto, there are some risks to consider when following the ketogenic diet long-term.
The mental, emotional, hormonal, cardiovascular, digestive, performance, and skeletal effects after years of following the diet for humans haven’t been vetted out yet. It’ll probably be a decade or two before we understand what happens when we restrict carbohydrates indefinitely.
The following are some of the long-term risks to consider when staying on keto after you achieve a solid level of health and fitness.
1. Chronically Elevated Cortisol
Physical, mental, or physiological stress stimulates cortisol secretion.
However, cortisol is also released when your body’s physiology gets out of balance.
Cortisol rises when your blood sugar is low in order to get glucose into your bloodstream. It does so by stimulating gluconeogenesis, the formation of glucose from amino acids. The amino acids come from either your diet or muscle tissue.
In the long-term, this could lead to muscle loss, especially if you don’t eat enough protein. Elevated cortisol also causes low testosterone in men and women.
Also, since keto could cause a stress response in some people, I would recommend not following a ketogenic diet if you are
- dealing with adrenal fatigue (also known as HPA Axis Dysregulation)
- the parent of a newborn
- an athletes in the midst of high volume training
- under significant work, financial, or relationship stress, unless the cause of that stress would be reduced by you getting your health and body composition under control
2. Growth Hormone Suppression and Resistance
Growth hormone stimulates fat metabolism and metabolic rate, supports muscle tissue growth and repair, and enhances thyroid function. It also increases ketone production.
Growth hormone levels increase in response to fasting, intense exercise, deep sleep, low blood sugar, and injury or trauma.
Theoretically, your low blood sugar from a ketogenic diet should stimulate growth hormone. However, there’s another factor that’s often overlooked.
Elevations in fatty acids blunt growth hormone secretion.
And what does a high-fat diet, ketogenic diet do? It increases fatty acid availability by either releasing more fatty acids from stored body fat, or from the higher levels of fat you consume on the diet.
One of the best ways to mitigate the blunting of growth hormone is to take a break from eating between meals. Growth hormone rises about three to four hours after a meal, when fatty acid or glucose levels fall.
But if you eat dark chocolate, fat bombs, nuts, drink fat-filled coffee, or consume other calorie-filled snacks between meals, you never reach a post-meal fasting state, which means your keto snacks could stifle growth hormone secretion.
Where carbs and fat blunt growth hormone, protein actually stimulates growth hormone release. It’s one of the many reasons I recommend at least 0.75 grams of protein per pound ideal body weight each day on keto, assuming you’re not treating a disease with the diet.
One other potential issue is growth hormone resistance.
A 2011 animal study by Bielohuby, et al., showed that a very low-carbohydrate diet caused the liver to become growth hormone-resistant, meaning growth hormone didn’t stimulate IGF-1 production normally.
Growth hormone doesn’t act directly on tissues to stimulate growth. It acts on insulin-like growth factors, with insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) being the most prominent.
It appears that the diet helps reduce or eliminate seizures by decreasing or suppressing IGF-1, as well as mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR). While that’s good for controlling seizures, it could be detrimental for lean body mass. Both IGF-1 and mTOR are factors in muscle growth.
3. Chronically Low Insulin
While chronically high insulin is certainly a problem, keeping insulin too low for too long could also present some problems.
Insulin is an extremely powerful anabolic hormone. Yes, it can cause fat gain when insulin, carbs, fat, and total calories are too high. But, it also enhances muscle growth by increasing amino acid uptake in muscle cells.
Without insulin, it will be increasingly difficult to build muscle and recover from strength training sessions.
Not only that, but low insulin might have a negative effect on your brain.
Recent research shows that insulin does more than store fat and amino acids. Insulin seems to be neuroprotective for your brain, and supports learning and memory. It also could slow the aging process.
The problem with insulin might not be insulin itself, but rather the resistance of cells to respond to insulin’s signals.
As I mentioned earlier, there is little long-term research on the effects of a ketogenic diet. As it stands today, I believe carbs should be part of one’s diet, once he or she has restored insulin sensitivity.
4. Low Thyroid
Thyroid function declines on a low-carb or ketogenic diet.
Those on the pro low-carb side say this is a natural effect from the body shifting fuel substrates.
Those on the anti-low-carb side often use the thyroid response as reason to recommend against it.
In my opinion, if you have hypothyroidism, and your treatment plan keeps your levels in an optimal range, just check your levels again within two to three months after starting keto, and see if there’s a change.
Besides a change in thyroid, you might notice an increase in cholesterol, a decrease in energy, or other hypothyroid symptoms.
A complete thyroid panel includes TSH, T3, T4, reverse T3, and Thyroid Peroxidase (TPO). You can easily check your levels with a complete thyroid home test kit.
If you have symptoms of hypothyroidism, and you’ve never gotten medical help, I would not recommend keto.
5. Digestive Dysfunction
Everyone agrees that the gut is a significant part of the immune system. It also acts like a second brain. Much of its value comes from the bacteria that live there.
Your gut can help you feel good through the production of neurotransmitters like serotonin. It can also make you feel miserable through autoimmune reactions and inflammation.
Excessive carbohydrates, and especially sugar, help bad bacteria spread like a California wildfire. Yet, even good gut bacteria needs some carbs, and especially fiber, to flourish.
We don’t know what the long-term effects of eating enormous amounts of fat, and little to no carbohydrates might do to the microbiomes of large populations of people.
Interestingly, researchers feed animals a high-fat diet to cause systemic inflammation and a breakdown of the gut lining. Then, they test various therapies to see how well they reduce the inflammation they triggered with the high-fat diet.
Some evidence, mainly from animal research, suggests that a high-fat intake increases cardiovascular disease risk by increasing production of endotoxins, also known as lipopolysaccharides (LPS).
No, we’re not rats or mice. But, it’s the increased fat that causes endotoxins, which increase inflammation.
One way to avoid this is by consuming more of your fat as medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs) as opposed to standard dietary fats. MCTs are metabolized differently, and don’t trigger LPS production.
From the existing research, a low-carb, high-fat diet in humans seems to lower levels of inflammation in the short-term. But there’s still much that’s unknown about the long-term changes of gut bacteria and the health of the gut lining itself.
To me, the biggest concern related to digestive health on keto is getting enough fiber.
Without sufficient fiber, your gut bacteria have no food. Without food, they die. The lettuce wrap around your bacon double-cheese burger isn’t enough quality fiber to feed your good bacteria.
Good bacteria produce neurotransmitters like serotonin. They also use prebiotic fibers like fructooligosaccharides to produce short-chain fatty acids (SFAs). The cells lining your gut then use the SFAs as an energy source, helping those cells thrive and multiply.
Without the SFAs, your gut lining breaks down, leading to autoimmune issues, as well as potential changes in mood and emotional state.
6. Depressed Mood & Emotions
Keto can help calm the mind and increase clarity and focus for those with hyperactivity or anxiety.
But what about those who are already chilled out, stoic, or emotionally reserved? Those who don’t get overly excited, but also don’t wig out over the unexpected? Could the lack of carbs leave some types of people feeling depressed?
There isn’t much research to answer these questions. Anecdotally, there are many examples of people who feel flat, depressed, or melancholic on keto.
When it comes to brain chemistry, people respond in opposite ways to certain substances. I’ve seen this phenomenon with supplements and essential oils. Perhaps you’ve seen it at a relatives wedding reception.
One friend is the life of the party after a few drinks. The other is asleep in a corner.
Observational studies have shown that LChD (low-carb diets) with high protein and fat concentrations are associated with higher levels of anxiety, anger, stress, mood disturbances, fatigue, depression, poor physical exercise performance, and less vigor and imagination.Frigolet et al.
One caveat: Almost everyone feels lousy during the adaptation period from sugar-burning to fat-burning. That’s not a problem with the diet or a reason for you not to do it. It’s just your brain and body getting over its dependence on glucose. It’s known as the keto flu.
So, don’t be surprised if you feel tired, ornery, irritable, or fatigued. You’ll just have to muster up some suckituptitude and get through it.
However, if you’ve been on keto for a while, and you’re no longer feeling like yourself, it might be time to indulge in some carbs.
On a personal note, I’d followed a low-carb or ketogenic diet for several years. I was so used to feeling emotionally and physically “flat” that I didn’t realize how off I felt. It wasn’t until I started tinkering with eating carbs at dinner more often that I started feeling (and sleeping) more like my old self.
7. Decreased Physical Performance
Keto is great for some types of endurance sports. Studies show fat oxidation, endurance, and peak power improve after adapting to a ketogenic diet.
However, keto doesn’t offer much benefit in power, strength, and glycogen-dependent sports and exercise. It could actually be detrimental for some sports.
If you’re brand new to exercise, and you’re not under significant amounts of stress, you’ll probably do well combining keto and a good strength training program.
If you’ve been training for years, and start a ketogenic diet, it’s possible you’ll experience a drop in strength, muscular endurance, and overall stamina.
Even for aerobic exercise, the performance improvements don’t always come from increased fatty acid utilization, but rather from the availability of ketones. It could be more effective for endurance athletes to continue to eat carbs, and supplement with exogenous ketones (explained below), rather than follow a ketogenic diet with or without ketones.
For every hardcore ketogenic athlete you find, you can find another who bonked, tanked, or crashed while trying to train hard following a ketogenic diet. There’s a high level of individuality for keto and sports performance.
Here’s what I often tell the guys in my VIGOR Training Facebook group:
If you’re overweight, do keto until you reach a plateau in weight loss, energy levels, or performance. If that plateau lasts more than a couple of weeks, eat an evening meal with whatever carbs you want, and see what happens over the next few days with your weight, performance, and energy levels.
Stick with it until it doesn’t work. Then eat your fill of carbs for dinner one night and see what happens. You’ll probably notice the weight starts coming off again, and your mood, energy, and performance improve for a while.
Then, when you hit a plateau again, eat the carbs for an afternoon again. You might benefit from including them on an occasionally (possibly weekly) basis.
That’s really what my 28 Days: Four Weeks Of Fat Loss plan is all about.
Top 9 Keto Diet Mistakes
Keto is rigid, but it’s simple. If you follow the rules of the diet, you have a very high probability of getting results. If you make up your own rules, or stick to it only when it’s convenient, you will probably fail.
The following are the Top 9 mistakes people make on the ketogenic diet.
1. Doing Keto Mostly Sometimes
I think our son Jacob coined the phrase “mostly sometimes” when he was around ten years old.
If you asked him, he “mostly sometimes” cleaned his room, brushed his teeth, and was nice to his brother.
He knew knew the “right answer” was yes, the “real answer” was no, and so he came up with a middle-ground answer. Mostly sometimes.
Many keto dieters believe they follow a ketogenic diet, but when you ask them what they ate that day, or the day before, or the day before that, they realize they’re doing keto mostly sometimes.
Keto is not a “mostly sometimes nutrition plan.” It is a diet.
Let me put it another way…if you half-ass keto, and eat more carbs than you should, it’s probably the worst nutrition plan you could follow. Combining carbs with a high-fat diet screws up lipid profiles, causes weight gain, and well…leads to almost all of the health problems people face today, since that’s pretty much the Standard American Diet: Lots of fat, too much carbohydrate, and too little protein.
You’re either in or out. All the time. Not mostly sometimes.
2. Not Maintaining Monogamy
When I trained clients one-on-one, I often told them that if they wanted to work with me, they could not cheat on me. They had to be monogamous.
I didn’t want them to follow my nutrition and exercise plan for a couple of weeks, and then start something else because their best friend just started it, or because it came packaged with a sexy-looking supplement.
I didn’t want them adding in a P90x workout on their off days, or doing an extra boot camp class after our sessions.
I knew that if they jumped from one program to the next, they’d never make progress.
It’s not that I believed I was the end-all-be-all trainer and nutrition coach. It’s that I knew they they’d get results if they followed my program consistently.
What I find is that people get a week or two into a diet, and then they start looking at other diets, thinking there’s a better option out there.
They’re all in on keto for a week. Then they’re onto Paleo and loading up on sweet potatoes. The next week they’re back to keto, and suffering through another fat adaptation phase. Then, they’re onto intermittent fasting and eating carbs at night. And then they join a friend for a Weight Watchers meeting where Oprah woos them into eating whatever they want.
Five diets in five weeks and they can’t figure out why things won’t work out for them.
Don’t play the field. Be a one-diet man or one-diet woman.
3. Not Eating Vegetables
Fiber provides food for the good bacteria in your digestive system. The bacteria, then, produce short-chain fatty acids which support the health of your gut lining.
I’ve met so many people who developed autoimmune issues and food sensitivities after following a low-carb or ketogenic diet. I’m certain that most of the time, the cause is the combination of ridiculous amounts of fat and virtually no fiber in their diet.
Don’t let the excitement of eating bacon keep you from eating broccoli. Without enough vegetables, you’ll not only end up with diarrhea, but you’ll also compromise your gut health and immune system.
Vegetables and organ meats are also your main source of food-based micronutrients on keto. If you’re like most people, you’re probably not eating much for organ meat, so it comes down to vegetables and some berries. While I always recommend a high-quality multivitamin, I also can’t overemphasize the importance of eating plenty of non-starchy vegetables.
If you’re not sure what to buy for groceries, download this simple keto shopping list.
4. Eating Too Much Fat
Say what?! I thought I got to eat as much fat as I wanted?!
You’re less likely to gain weight on keto when you overeat, but if you eat too much fat, you won’t need to burn body fat for energy. And that’s kind of the point, right? You won’t get fatter, but you probably won’t get leaner either.
If you eat too much fat, your body uses the fat from your food instead of the fat in your saddle bags, love handles, moobs, muffin top, and beer belly.
Gorging on fat bombs, butter, and drinking pints of heavy cream isn’t going to get you results. Also, eating that much fat has a way of sliding right through you.
Overdo the fat, and it can move through you so fast you’ll feel like you’re Jeff Bridges in Dumb and Dumber.
While the ketogenic diet provides a plethora of health benefits, it’s not the fat free-for-all solution that’s the antithesis to the fat-free for all dietary dogma of the past several decades.
5. Neglecting Weight Training
Don’t lose muscle.
That’s one of my mantras whenever I make nutrition, lifestyle, and fitness recommendations.
If you don’t strength train, you will lose muscle. In fact, your rate of muscle loss on keto could be faster than other diets, since you’re more likely to have elevated cortisol, low insulin, compromised sleep, and low growth hormone.
Whether your goal is weight loss or you want to simply stay healthy and fit, weight training is a necessary part of maintaining a healthy body.
Beyond that, though, weight training improves insulin sensitivity, increases your capacity to store glucose, increases testosterone and growth hormone production, and gives you something to show off as you drop body fat.
Weight training and walking are the two most important physical activities on a ketogenic diet.
That’s not to say you can’t do cardio, yoga, Pilates, ballroom dancing, or play pickle ball (which is a blast). But, the most important thing you can do is to follow a good, progressive strength training program.
You need to lift weights.
6. Not Getting Enough Electrolytes
Insulin helps you retain sodium. When insulin is low, you excrete more sodium.
You need sodium to work with potassium for normal heart rhythm and muscle contraction. You also need sodium to maintain normal blood pressure.
If you don’t intentionally add salt to your diet while on keto, you might get lightheaded, cause low blood pressure, and feel more fatigued than usual.
Drink at least half your body weight in ounces of water each day, but do it Himalayan style. Add some pink Himalayan salt to your water bottle.
The salt adds sodium to your water, and has dozens of other trace minerals in it.
If you don’t have Himalayan, and you’re feeling the effects of low blood pressure, go ahead and use Morton’s (it’s got the girl with the umbrella) or another iodized salt. The Paleo police might not condone such behavior, but it’s probably better to keep your blood pressure normal, and get the better salt when you can.
7. Constant Snacking
Whether or not you’re on keto, you need periods of fasting and periods of feeding.
Growth hormone levels rise about 3-4 hours after a meal, assuming you don’t snack in the meantime.
A snack is anything that contains calories.
Learn to experience the feeling of true hunger. Ghrelin, the hormone that makes your stomach growl, is also the hormone that stimulates growth hormone.
Unless you’re a competitive athlete, or a growing adolescent, you don’t to need eat as often as you pee.
Most people don’t need to eat more than three times per day, and you might even do better with two.
That doesn’t mean you can’t eat your favorite keto snack food. Just eat it when you sit down for your meal, not between meals.
8. Comparing Ketones
Too many people get obsessed with measuring their ketone level.
They end up eating ridiculous amounts of fat and minimal protein, just to get a higher number on a ketone meter.
The point of being on keto is to improve your health and fitness. It is not to win a blood ketone contest.
9. Overcomplicating Keto
The more complex you make the diet, the less likely it is that you’ll follow through with it.
Eat mostly fats, some protein, some non-starchy vegetables, very few carbs.
The statement above is stupid-simple.
It’s as easy as eating fatty cuts of meat, and adding some butter to your cooked vegetables, or olive oil to your salad dressing.
Unfortunately, instead of just going with it as-is, people overcomplicate it.
For example, rather than just taking “mostly fats” at face value, they keep reading articles and books, and then get confused about what “eat mostly fats” even means.
Instead of just eating more fat, they ask more questions and take no action.
What type of fats do I need to eat? Can I cook with it? Can I add it to my coffee? What time of day should I start eating it? Can I eat the fat with the protein or should it be by itself? Does it have to have a certain amount of omega-3s? Omega-6s? MCTs? What coconut oil is best? What if I buy the wrong brand?
Does my cream need to come from the utter of a grass-fed cow born in New Zealand with exactly two spots on its right side in the shapes of unicorns?
Too far? It was the unicorns that went too far. Sorry.
My point is, you don’t have to overcomplicate things. Eat food, mostly fat, some protein, some non-starchy vegetables, and very little carbohydrate.
It’s okay to have a growing interest in nutrition. It’s interesting! But, don’t let your need to start, and make progress, become an obsession with doing things perfectly.
There is no “perfect” when it comes to nutrition.
If you never read another nutrition book or article, you’d have everything you need right here to successfully use keto to get great results.
Go to the store, and fill your cart with:
- Meat, fish, poultry, eggs, whey protein
- Cheese (if you tolerate dairy), avocado, nuts, heavy cream, coconut oil
- Fibrous vegetables like leafy greens, broccoli, cauliflower, eggplant, cucumbers, dill pickles
Bring the food home and eat:
- Eat ~0.75 grams of protein per pound ideal body weight, spread out over your meals for the day (that “~” sign means about, not “exactly”).
- Eat 30 grams or fewer of net carbohydrates each day.
- Add enough fat to keep you full, and seeing weekly weight loss.
- Don’t snack.
That’s it. It’s that simple to get started with the nutrition part of keto.
Often, people fall into one of two camps with nutritional supplements. Either they believe they’re only necessary in special circumstances, and that most don’t work, or they buy supplements left and right, hoping they’ll cover up their poor dietary and lifestyle choices. Neither point of view does justice to how supplements work, and why you should include them in your nutrition program.
I’ve always told my clients to look at certain supplements as part of their monthly grocery budget. Just as you need to buy and eat vegetables and protein, you also need to buy and take some high-quality supplements.
If you see supplements as a luxury, or something you’d invest in when you get “serious” about your nutrition, you’re seriously missing out.
In addition, due to the restrictive nature of a ketogenic diet, you do risk creating some micronutrient deficiencies by relying on food alone.
The following is a starter list of supplements which may help you with your health and fitness goals while doing keto.
No supplement is so good that it can undo the effects of a lousy diet. No diet is so good that you can’t benefit from supplementation.
A high-quality multivitamin has ranked at the top of my most-recommended supplements for as long as I can remember.
Vegetables, fruit, and organ meats are the most nutrient-dense foods you can eat. Unfortunately, most people don’t like the taste or texture of organ meats. They also don’t eat nearly enough vegetables and fruit.
Being on keto, you don’t get to eat more than a couple handfuls of berries. And even though I implore you to eat a ton of fibrous vegetables, most people don’t do it.
So, the first supplement I recommend is a high-quality multivitamin.
After a high-quality multivitamin, fish oil is my second most-recommended supplement for general health and wellness.
Obviously, you get to eat a lot of fat on keto, but unless you eat fatty fish most days, you won’t get much omega-3 fat. Without supplementing with fish oil, you have the potential to tip the scales too much towards pro-inflammatory omega-6 fats.
In a study that used human blood samples, EPA+DHA intake changed the expression of 1040 genes and resulted in a decreased expression of genes involved in inflammatory and atherogenesis-related pathways.Bouwens et al. Am J Clin Nutr. 2009
About 70% of the population consumes less than optimal levels of magnesium alone, and a ketogenic diet may speed up the rate of mineral use.
You may also notice that you experience muscle cramps more often as you get going on your ketogenic diet. Salting your water, and supplementing with magnesium may help with the cramps.
Most high-quality multivitamins don’t contain much calcium and magnesium. It’s not because the manufacturer is cutting corners. It’s because these minerals, when in supplement form like magnesium bisglycinate, take up a ton of space.
A good daily dose of the magnesium alone usually requires three to four capsules, so you’ll want to take these along with your multi.
Read more: What You Need to Know About Magnesium.
The health of your gut is connected to your brain, immune system, hormones, micronutrient levels, and so much more.
Your diet is the most important factor in the types of bacteria that live in your gut.
For example, excess sugar is connected with SIBO and Candida. Lower-sugar and higher-fiber diets are associated with healthier guts and overall improved wellbeing.
A shift from a western diet to keto causes a dramatic change in your gut.
Those who neglect to eat enough fresh, non-starchy vegetables literally starve their gut bacteria.
To help populate your gut with good bacteria, I’d recommend a couple of different high-quality probiotics.
With thousands of different probiotic strains in our environment, it’s probably wise to expose your digestive system to a variety of bacteria. Then, as you continue to take your probiotics, keep eating high-fiber foods to feed them.
As the bacteria feed on fiber, they not only multiply, but they also release short-chain fatty acids (SFAs), which promote the health of your intestinal lining as well as stimulate formation of additional ketones.
Feeding the fiber to the good bacteria helps take you deeper into ketosis!
Read more: Health Benefits of Probiotics: Your Guide
Research shows berberine inhibits inflammation, turns on genes involved in raising metabolic rate, turns off genes involved in fat storage, and enhances insulin sensitivity.
Some studies indicate its effect on blood sugar rivals Metformin.
Supplementing with berberine has been also shown to increase short-chain fatty acid production by gut bacteria, without any change to fiber in the diet. Like fiber, berberine can be especially powerful for gut health.
With it also supporting insulin sensitivity, and normal blood sugar and cholesterol, it’s a perfect supplement for keto.
Medium-chain triglycerides, or MCTs, are a specific type of fat which is absorbed through the stomach differently than most other fats.
Most fats require bile, and in excess, can create endotoxins, which increase inflammation. MCTs are absorbed without the need for bile and do not cause endotoxin formation.
As great as that sounds, if you use too much, too quickly, you will get diarrhea.
Research shows that people might be able to maintain nutritional ketosis without being quite as strict on their diet when supplementing with MCTs.
Where a typical ketogenic diet includes only about 5% of calories from carbohydrate, carbohydrate intake could be tripled, provided enough of the fat came from MCTs.
The key here, though, is that the MCTs replaced some of the dietary fat to allow that to happen.
Coconut oil is often marketed as being a rich source of MCTs, but the concentration is very low. You won’t get a therapeutic effect from the coconut oil, and would need to supplement with straight MCTs to get the benefits described in the research.
If you have any concerns about the amount of fat used in the ketogenic diet, consider swapping a good portion of your daily dietary fat intake with MCT oil. Just take your time in swapping one for another.
Start with a teaspoon once per day, working up to a teaspoon with each meal, and then increase the amount with each meal.
Why with your meals? Remember the section on snacking under keto mistakes?
Taking MCTs raises fatty acid levels, like food would. If you want the post-meal growth hormone secretion, you need to avoid food between meals, so both your blood sugar and fatty acid levels return to baseline, stimulating growth hormone.
If you like them in your morning cup of coffee, be sure to wait for at least four hours afterwards to eat your first meal.
Exogenous means “from outside the body,” which contrasts with endogenous ketones, the ketones your body makes in response to the diet.
Exogenous ketones are supplements that deliver the very same ketones you produce in your body, through a supplement form.
Though exogenous ketones have been studied for decades, they’ve only recently become commercially available.
The research related to their use is exciting, even for those who may not follow a ketogenic diet.
Exogenous ketones come in ketone mineral salts and ketone esters. Though the esters seem to work better, they’re very difficult to flavor, and taste awful. At this point, they’re not commercially available.
Research shows exogenous ketones lower blood glucose, whether one is on a ketogenic diet or not. They also decrease free fatty acid levels in the blood, and may help calm the mind for those with anxiety.
The elevation in blood ketones, following their consumption, causes the liver and muscle cells to take up glucose and fatty acids.
This is different from nutritional ketosis, which also causes lower blood sugar levels, but maintains or elevates free fatty acids levels.
Also, exogenous ketones may reduce the liver’s production of endogenous ketones. Since the body recognizes that ketone levels are elevated, it may shut down its own production until the exogenous ketones are used up.
Exogenous ketones do not cause ketosis. Rather they mimic some of the effects of being in nutritional ketosis.
Because the exogenous ketones cause a drop in blood sugar, those who are not on a ketogenic diet, but use ketones, may notice the drop in blood sugar more than those who already have lower blood sugar levels.
If you’re on medication to manage blood sugar, connect with your doctor before using exogenous ketones, and monitor your blood sugar levels closely.
Because cortisol rises when blood sugar drops, cortisol levels have been shown to increase after supplementing with exogenous ketones.
For most people, it’s probably not an issue and would be a short-term effect, but in the small percentage of people who have chronically elevated cortisol, it would be something to at least be aware of.
If you react quickly to the ketones, the drop in blood sugar could make you feel jittery, raise your heart rate, or cause some other temporary stress response. This is more likely to happen if you’re not following a ketogenic diet, and use the ketones, than if you’re already keeping blood sugar levels low.
One other word of caution is for those with high blood pressure. Exogenous ketones today are often made by combining the ketone to sodium, so your sodium intake would increase quite a bit with their use. If you use exogenous ketones, then you probably don’t need to worry about salting your water, like I discussed about above.
If you’re being treated by a doctor for high blood pressure, be sure to consult him or her before making significant changes to your diet or supplement plan.
Exogenous ketone supplementation is an exciting area of research, and there’s still much to be learned. At this point, research shows they provide a unique dietary advantage in that you can experience the benefits of ketones without necessarily being on a ketogenic diet.
However, your health and fitness are surely to improve more from using exogenous ketones with a low-carb or ketogenic diet, rather than simply using the exogenous ketones as dietary supplements with a western diet.
Whether the exogenous ketones enhance physical performance remains to be seen. Muscle cells are less effective than other tissues at ketone uptake.
At low levels of ketosis, up to half of the ketones are taken up by muscle, but as ketone levels rise, muscle uptake drops to as little as 5% of ketone availability. It seems muscle cells get saturated quickly.
Prüvit deserves much credit, not just for bringing exogenous ketones into mainstream health and fitness, but also for helping to spread the word about the ketogenic diet.
Their rapid growth is due to their network marketing model, which incentivizes one person to spread the word to another.
Frankly, I don’t think keto itself would be anywhere near as popular today, if it weren’t for Prüvit distributors talking about it within the context of the exogenous ketones they promote.
That said, some network marketers do exaggerate health claims and spread misinformation. If you’re getting most of your keto guidance from someone who sells the product, you might want to verify it through someone else.
Though I’ve used their exogenous ketones myself, I have no affiliation with Prüvit (nor do I plan to, as I’m already happily involved with another business).
That’s not to say another brand’s exogenous ketones wouldn’t also be effective. I’ve just been impressed with the products, as well as the company’s commitment to support ongoing research and development.
If you’re interested in trying them out too, you probably won’t need to scroll through more than 20 people on your Facebook newsfeed to see somebody advertising them.
What Do You Do After Keto?
As fascinating and buzz-worthy as the ketogenic diet is, there’s still more unknown about the long-term influence of carbohydrate restriction, than is known.
Committing to one way of eating is far more difficult mentally than physically.
To convince themselves that the diet they’re on is the right one to follow, people often paint the picture of their diet as the hero, and all others as the villains.
They start to speak of the foods that fit into their nutrition plan as though they’re delivered by the hand of God, and the foods that don’t fit in the plan as though they came from the devil.
I’ve been guilty of this myself.
Carbs are not evil. Sugar is not poison.
I need to emphasize this because, as compelling as keto is for dealing with disease, and even for improving health in the short-term, nobody knows what the long term effects of avoiding one of the three macronutrients will be.
I believe we can benefit from carbs when they’re not eaten at every meal or in excess. That includes some sugar, too.
I fear that as a society, momentum behind keto will grow. People will avoid carbohydrates altogether, and in another decade, we’ll realize that long-term carbohydrate restriction wasn’t healthy either.
Please don’t misinterpret what I’m saying. Insulin resistance, obesity, diabetes, and many of the neurodegenerative diseases linked to all of this, in my opinion, are tied to carbohydrate intolerance.
Just as when you spend too much time in the sun, you get burned. When you overdo carbohydrates, you can do much damage. But, in the right doses, sun exposure is critical for your health. I believe the same will be discovered about carbohydrates.
I believe a proper balance of fat and carbohydrate will be eventually discovered.
Will it be that our bodies do best with eating carbs for a season like summer, and then are better hibernating through the winter on fat and protein?
Will intermittent fasting make it easier to experience ketosis, while also eating carbs on a periodic basis?
Will eating an excessive amount of fat be found to do harm, just as excessive carbohydrates do?
These are a tiny fraction of the questions that remain unanswered.
The best thing you can do for your health is to remain committed to something long enough to see results, but flexible enough that you’ll be open to a new way of thinking, when researchers uncover new discoveries.